The Dominance Myth: Your Chow Isn't Being 'Pack Leader'
'He's being dominant.'
I hear it a lot. About growling. About pulling on the lead. About a Chow who won't get off the sofa. About a Chow who goes through doors first.
So let's look at where that idea came from, and what we know now.
Where 'alpha' came from
Much of the alpha idea is usually traced back to studies of captive wolves in the mid 20th century. These were unrelated adult wolves, put together in an enclosure. Unsurprisingly, there was tension.
Wolf researcher L. David Mech helped spread the 'alpha' term in a 1970 book. He later spent years studying wild wolves, and found that most packs are simply families. Parents and their offspring. The 'alphas' are usually just mum and dad.
Mech has since asked people to stop using the term.
Dogs aren't wolves anyway
Dogs and wolves share ancestors, but dogs have been living alongside people for a very long time. Scientists still debate exactly when and where dogs were first domesticated, but most estimates put it at least 15,000 years ago. Our dogs don't think we're wolves. And they aren't plotting to take over the house.
The American Veterinary Society of Animal Behavior has a position statement warning against using dominance theory to explain most problem behaviour in dogs, and against training methods based on it.
To be fair, some researchers do still use 'dominance' to describe relationships between dogs over particular resources. But it isn't a personality type, and it doesn't explain most problems between dogs and their people.
What's really going on
When owners tell me their Chow is being dominant, the real reason is usually one of these:
- Fear or worry. Growling at visitors, guarding a space.
- Pain or discomfort. Snapping when touched, especially in an older Chow.
- Resource guarding. Protecting food, toys or a favourite spot.
- Learnt behaviour. Pulling works, so they keep pulling.
- Not understanding the cue in that place, or with that level of distraction.
None of these are fixed by 'showing them who's boss'.
Why it matters for your Chow
Dominance-based methods often rely on physical pressure, intimidation or punishment. Research has linked aversive methods with more stress in dogs, and with a higher risk of aggression.
In my experience, a Chow who's pushed around often stops warning before they bite. That's the last thing anyone wants.
What works instead
- Build trust. Your Chow should feel safe with you.
- Reward what you like. Behaviour that's rewarded is repeated.
- Manage the environment. Prevent the behaviour you don't want from happening.
- Look for the reason. Ask why, not 'how do I win'.
- Check health. A vet check is a sensible first step for any sudden change in behaviour.
Quick answers
Are Chow Chows dominant dogs?
Labelling a Chow as dominant rarely helps. Behaviours like growling, guarding or ignoring cues usually have other explanations, such as fear, discomfort, guarding something valuable or a gap in training.
Where did the alpha wolf idea come from?
From early studies of unrelated captive wolves. Later research on wild wolves found packs are usually family groups, and the scientist who popularised the term has since asked people to stop using it.
Do I need to be the pack leader with my Chow?
No. You need to be someone your Chow trusts. Clear routines, rewards for what you like and good management work far better than trying to dominate them.
Now it's your turn
Next time you catch yourself thinking 'they're being dominant', stop and ask a different question. 'What is my Chow feeling right now, and what do they need?' Write down your answer. It'll often point straight at the solution.
If there's a behaviour you're struggling with, book a 1:1 consultation and we'll find out what's really going on.
Want a tip like this every week? Join my free Sunday newsletter and get the Chow Chow Basics guide too.

