Why Force-Free Training? What the Research Really Says

October 28, 2026

I'm a force-free trainer. That means I don't use pain, fear or intimidation to train dogs.

People sometimes think that means letting dogs do whatever they like. It doesn't. So here's what it does mean, and why so many vets and behaviour professionals now recommend it.

Kenny Cook rewarding two Chow Chows on a woodland walk

What 'aversive' means

An aversive is something a dog finds unpleasant enough to want to avoid. In training, that might be:

  • Lead jerks or 'corrections'
  • Choke, prong or electric shock collars
  • Spray bottles, shake cans or throwing things
  • Shouting, physical pressure or pinning a dog down

What the research says

Over the last 20 years, quite a few studies have compared training methods.

A study published in 2020 by Ana Catarina Vieira de Castro and colleagues compared dogs from reward-based and aversive training schools in Portugal. Dogs from aversive schools showed more stress behaviours during training, higher stress hormone levels afterwards, and a more 'pessimistic' outlook in a separate test.

Other reviews have reached similar conclusions. Reward-based methods are generally at least as effective, with fewer welfare risks.

Research has also linked confrontational methods with a higher risk of aggressive responses from dogs.

The law is changing

  • Wales banned the use of electric shock collars in 2010.
  • England banned their use from February 2024.
  • Scotland has guidance discouraging their use, and Northern Ireland has no specific law, at the time of writing.
  • In the US, shock collars are legal in most states.
  • Several other European countries restrict or ban them.

Laws change, so check what applies where you live.

Why it matters for Chows

In my experience, Chows often respond badly to physical pressure. Many are sensitive and independent, and they tend to remember who made them feel unsafe.

A Chow who learns that training is scary may shut down, or may start to defend themselves. Neither is what you want.

What force-free training looks like

  • Rewarding the behaviour you want. Food, play, sniffing, praise.
  • Management. Gates, leads and planning, so unwanted behaviour doesn't get practised.
  • Teaching alternatives. Sit to greet instead of jumping. Look at you instead of lunging.
  • Clear boundaries. Rules, routines and consistency.
  • Looking at the why. Fear, pain and frustration all drive behaviour.

Quick answers

Is force-free training proven to work?

Research comparing methods generally finds reward-based training is at least as effective as aversive methods, with fewer welfare risks such as stress, fear and aggression.

Are electric shock collars banned in the UK?

Their use is banned in Wales and, since February 2024, in England. Rules differ in Scotland, Northern Ireland and other countries, and many US states allow them.

Does force-free mean no rules?

No. Force-free training still has clear boundaries. It uses management, rewards and good planning instead of pain, fear or intimidation.

Now it's your turn

Look at the equipment you use with your Chow. If any of it works by causing discomfort, write down what you'd replace it with. A well-fitted harness, a longer lead, better treats. Start with one swap this week.

If you'd like help moving to force-free methods, book a 1:1 consultation.

Want a tip like this every week? Join my free Sunday newsletter and get the Chow Chow Basics guide too.

Back to Blog